Affordability is one of the most searched topics in American real estate — and for good reason. Over the past decade, home values have outpaced income growth in most major metros, squeezing both first-time buyers and renters. But pockets of affordability remain, and Census data lets us identify them with precision.
How We Measure Affordability
CensusDepth's affordability index blends three ACS 5-year metrics: median home value, median gross rent, and median household income. We compute a price-to-income ratio for homeowners and a rent-to-income ratio for renters, then combine them into a single composite score. Lower scores equal higher affordability.
The 10 Most Affordable Large Cities
Among cities with populations above 100,000 in the 2023 ACS, these ten rank highest on our affordability composite:
- Detroit, MI — Median home value $66,000, median household income $36,000. The price-to-income ratio of 1.8x is the lowest of any large US city.
- Cleveland, OH — Home values averaging $90,000 against a median income of $35,000. Rent burden is also comparatively low.
- Memphis, TN — Strong job market recovery post-2020 with home values still well below national medians.
- Buffalo, NY — One of the few northeastern cities where median home values remain under $150,000.
- St. Louis, MO — A large metro anchor with city home values averaging $160,000 against incomes near $50,000.
- Toledo, OH — Consistently ranks in the top tier for rent affordability; median gross rent is under $800/month.
- Louisville, KY — Home values at 2.6x median income, well below the national average of 4.8x.
- Indianapolis, IN — Rapid population growth without the affordability destruction seen in Sun Belt boomtowns.
- Kansas City, MO — Solid income growth and a housing stock that hasn't seen speculative appreciation.
- Pittsburgh, PA — Despite being a tech hub, median home values remain well below $200,000 citywide.
What Drives Affordability?
Several factors cluster in affordable cities. Housing stock age matters — cities with older, denser housing built before the mid-20th century often have lower values simply because units are smaller and less amenity-rich. Population trends also matter: cities that experienced population loss over decades have structural housing surpluses that keep prices anchored.
Check the home value rankings for all cities or filter by state to find affordable options in your region. For renters specifically, the rent rankings show where monthly housing costs are lowest relative to local incomes.
A Caution on Affordability Rankings
Affordability data reflects averages across entire city boundaries — which can mask wide intra-city variation. A city's median home value might be $150,000 while a specific neighborhood averages $400,000. For granular analysis, look at county-level data and census tract profiles, which are available for every tract in America.
Affordability also doesn't exist in isolation. A "cheap" city with high vacancy, low employment, and poor public services may not be a practical choice even if the price-to-income ratio looks attractive. Use affordability rankings as one input among many.